This is a really interesting reflection on The Exhibition of People's Technology, 1972. Packed full of nuggets of wisdom over what the Alternative Technology folk got wrong back then, or what they tried that sort-of worked and why it wasn't a good answer.
It should be required reading for modern makers, particularly those looking to making to help with climate and/or equitable society.
https://zenodo.org/record/7336065#.ZBFeMi8w1pQ
via @ckohtala
I'm somewhat heartened to see that two of their mistakes were to aim for labour-intensive solutions, and not to realise that the Arts and Crafts approach is only a solution for the well-off; given that they're parts that felt like mistakes to me. Not that I've yet worked out (or proven at least) quite what the alternative is.
It would be good to capture my current thinking about all of this.
Re-reading http://www.mcqn.net/mcfilter/archives/thinking/is_the_maker_movement_a_movement.html I think that captures my critique of Arts and Crafts.
And https://indie.mcqn.com/blog/2016/11/27/a-brief-critique-of-ship-bits-not-atoms.html grasps at the trade-offs between individual craft and mass manufacture.
But there's something of a new Mittelstand in scale, combined with co-operative and collective ownership that's missing from them both.